FCC Mandated Requirements for E911 Call Location
Network-based solutions
Handset-based solutions
|
Competing Technologies
Polaris products deliver superior performance and cost advantages. Powerful wireless signature technology enables Polaris products to outperform other solutions in dense urban and indoor environments where line-of-sight is not always available. Polaris products have greater accuracy and reliability and lower ownership and maintenance costs compared to other network-based solutions in suburban and rural environments.
| |
Technology |
Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Handset-based Systems |
A-GPS |
- High accuracy in “open sky” conditions
- Moderate deployment costs for system's network component
|
- Must replace handsets
- Higher handset costs & long replacement cycles
- Yield and accuracy issues in urban canyons & indoors
|
| Network-based Systems |
TDOA and AOA |
- Moderate accuracy
- Works with existing handsets
|
- Must add overlay receiver network & expensive LMU hardware to each cell site
- Very high deployment costs
- Problems with non line-of-sight conditions
- Coverage problems in rural areas
|
| Wireless Location Signatures |
- Moderate accuracy
- Works with existing handsets
- Expedited deployment times
- Significantly lower total cost of ownership compared to TDOA and AOA
|
- Coverage issues in rural areas, but performs better than TDOA & AOA
|
Technology Comparison
| |
Wireless Location Signatures |
TDOA & AOA |
A-GPS |
| Handset Requirements |
None |
None |
Hardware and software modifications |
| Network Requirements |
Standard data interfaces |
Major modifications to base stations
with LMU hardware for each cellsite |
Data interfaces |
| Location Accuracy |
Moderate |
Moderate |
High in open sky |
| Coverage Reliability |
High |
Inconsistent due to line-of-sight and geometry requirements |
Inconsistent for urban canyons and indoors |
| Implementation Cost |
Low |
Extremely high |
High for handsets |
| Operation Cost |
Low |
High |
Low |
Polaris Wireless Location Signatures (WLS™) Benefits
Accuracy
- Meets the FCC E911 Phase II mandate now
- Enhances location accuracy for standard or A-GPS phones, no matter which wireless air interface is used
- Makes location-based services viable and practical
Reliability
- Uses existing network data and standard interfaces
- Locates callers accurately in 100% of cases
Timeliness
- Meets public safety requirements now
- Faster to deploy than other network-based hardware solutions
- Shortens time-to-market for commercial services
Flexibility
- Deploy stand-alone or side-by-side with existing technology
- Complements A-GPS technology
- Cover the entire handset base immediately
Savings
- No additional network hardware
- Works with existing handsets -- no changes required
- Low cost of ownership
- Extensible platform supports future network technologies and applications
|